Migration from L2TP to OpenVPN: Scalable and Reliable VPN Connectivity

Migration from L2TP to OpenVPN: the solution for stable, scalable, and load-balanced connectivity

In modern network environments, ensuring reliable and high-performance VPN connectivity is critical — especially as the number of connected devices grows exponentially. In this article, we examine the reasons that led us to migrate our VPN tunneling from L2TP to OpenVPN, highlight the issues we encountered, and describe the solution we implemented to achieve a seamless transition with zero impact on customers.

L2TP Pain Points in On-Premises Deployments

Load issues One of the main problems observed in on-premises deployments was related to workload. On certain processors, once the number of connected devices exceeded 600, the system experienced unexpected crashes. This scalability ceiling — caused by the intensive connection-handling demands of L2TP — made it clear that a more capable VPN solution was needed: one able to handle a larger volume of traffic and simultaneous connections.

NAT limitations A further obstacle emerged in NAT environments, where all connected devices share the same IP address. In this scenario, L2TP showed significant limitations, preventing devices from connecting correctly. Managing sessions under shared NAT required a more flexible and robust solution capable of reliably identifying and handling each connection.

Why OpenVPN? OpenVPN proved to be a solid alternative for overcoming the issues described above. Its main advantages are:

• Scalability and robustness: OpenVPN is designed to handle a high number of simultaneous connections without suffering from the hardware constraints that penalized L2TP.
• Advanced session management: OpenVPN's ability to operate in complex NAT environments enables more effective session handling, eliminating the shared-IP problem.
• Operational flexibility: Thanks to a more modular configuration and extensive customization options, OpenVPN adapts quickly to diverse network requirements, delivering greater reliability.

Handling Scalability A key architectural consideration with OpenVPN is that it operates in single-core mode. To overcome this limitation, we adopted a horizontal scaling strategy based on deploying multiple OpenVPN instances. Specifically, by leveraging IP Tables with the statistics module, we were able to distribute connections evenly across the different instances. This approach made it possible to:

• Balance the load: Distribute connections efficiently, making full use of the available hardware resources.
• Improve performance: Ensure optimal handling even when a large number of simultaneous connections are present.
• Increase resilience: Guarantee that the failure of a single instance does not compromise the entire service, maintaining high reliability standards.

The Solution: a Dynamic Migration Script To ensure a disruption-free transition, we developed a script that automates the switchover while keeping the credential management system and Radius integration unchanged. Here is how the process works:

1. Change scheduling: The script runs periodically via a scheduler. At the predefined time, L2TP mode is disabled.
2. OpenVPN activation: The script then enables the OpenVPN connection, preserving the same authentication logic and IP assignment.
3. Reachability test: Once the connection is up, a reachability test is performed to verify that the OpenVPN configuration is working correctly.
4. Automatic rollback: If the test fails, the system performs an immediate rollback. In this scenario, OpenVPN is disabled, L2TP is re-enabled, and a notification is sent to report the event.
5. Transparent transition: Thanks to this control mechanism, the migration happens in a completely transparent manner, with no impact on the end-user experience.

Benefits of the Migration Adopting OpenVPN — supported by an automated migration script and advanced scalability management — has delivered numerous benefits:

• Reliability: By eliminating the crash issues caused by high load, the new system ensures greater stability even in environments with a large number of devices.
• Flexibility in NAT environments: OpenVPN's advanced session management enables stable connectivity even when multiple devices share the same IP address, overcoming the limitation encountered with L2TP.
• Improved scalability: Deploying multiple OpenVPN instances, balanced via IP Tables and the statistics module, allows traffic to be handled efficiently while making the most of available hardware resources.
• Zero user impact: The automatic rollback capability ensures that, should any issue arise, the system immediately reverts to its previous operational state, guaranteeing service continuity.
• Centralized management: By retaining the same credential management and Radius integration, the implementation required no substantial changes to other network components, simplifying adoption of the new technology.

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Stay up to date on industry topics and OptiWize features

• • Required field

• Enter a valid email address

• Enter a valid name

• Enter a valid phone number

• Value is too small

• • Required field

• Enter a valid email address

• Enter a valid name

• Enter a valid phone number

• Value is too small

By clicking the button you accept our Privacy Policy

Would you like to explore a topic further? Fill in the form and we will get back to you as soon as possible

Email First name Last name Mobile Number of devices

0

10000+

• • Required field

• Enter a valid email address

• Enter a valid name

• Enter a valid phone number

• Value is too small

• • Required field

• Enter a valid email address

• Enter a valid name

• Enter a valid phone number

• Value is too small